608-687-7572 Mon-Fri: 10 am to 4 pm (CST)

Create an Account

Personal Information
Login Information



We pay top dollar for your sealed toys! Submit a list of your toys to get a quote for your collection, ship your toys and get paid fast!


Before we can send you a quote, we will need a list of what you have to sell. Check out our Webapp and Price My Toys mobile app for the quickest ways to make a list!

Webapp: Select the toy line you are selling and add each item individually. Search and sort the toys with the options at the top of the page. Click "Submit" and fill out contact info to send your list.

Price My Toys: Download the Price My Toys mobile app & scan the barcodes on your toys to create a list! Tap "Get Quote" to submit your list.


Quote Options
InstantQuote WebappPrice My Toys Mobile App

InstantQuote WebApp

Response Time: 1-2 Business Days

Open this webapp in your browser to quickly and efficiently receive your quote. Select the toy brand you are interested in selling

Price My Toys App

Response Time: 1-2 Business Days

Download the mobile app and scan barcodes of your toys to create a list. Submit for a quote!

      Download Price My Toys   Download Price My Toys for Android


For sizeable discounts on shipping and no cost upfront, use our UPS shipping account! Your shipping cost will be deducted from your payment. 

When we receive your collection, we will confirm its value. The price may fluctuate based on the actual condition of the items. We will confirm any changes with you.



After finalizing the offer you get paid! Payment will be sent within 1-2 business days. Choose between Direct Deposit, PayPal or a check by mail for your payment.

PayPal charges a 3% fee, and checks allow some extra time to be processed.

Alternative Quote Options
InstantQuote FormPrice My Toys Mobile App

InstantQuote Form

Response Time:

1-2 Business Days

Download the InstantQuote Excel checklist and then e-mail the completed form to us.

Note: Microsoft Excel 2007 or later is required.

PDF Checklist

Response Time:

4-7 Business Days

Alternatively, download our checklist in a printer-friendly format. This option is best for those who rather manually make a list. Blank submission forms are also available.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you buy loose toys and action figures?
We only purchase loose Vintage Star Wars figures. We do not purchase any other branded loose toys, figurines, or sets. The value of collectibles signifacantly drops when the packaging is opened. We recommend passing down or donating your loose toys so they can be enjoyed by others.
What does C-9 mean?
C-9 is part of our scale to determine the condition of items. The "C" stands for condition, and the number corresponds to the quality of the item on a scale of 1 to 10. For instance, 10 is excellent and 1 is extremely Poor condition. Our buylist reflects the prices we are paying for C-9 condition items. The price we pay for your item will adjust if the condition quality is higher or lower than a C-9.
Do I have to create a list? Can I send photos?
We discourage sending us photos that are unaccompnied with a list. We are in contact with many sellers a day, which does not yield enough time to dissect photographs from sellers who do not adhere to our process.
Do you guys allow trade?
Absolutely! We offer a 25% extra for trade-in credit towards merchandise that we sell on brianstoys.com. This option is perfect for collectors who have a little extra but want to stay in the game.
Does Brian's Toys pay for shipping?
Packaging and shipping costs are the responsibility of you the seller. However, we offer the option to ship on our UPS account at cheaper rates. The shipping fees will then be deducted from the payment to you.
Do I have a double-telescoping lightsaber Luke/Vader/Ben?
We get asked this question almost everytime someone is selling their vintage collection. The answer is NO about 99% of the time we're asked. The double-telescoping Luke skywalker, Darth Vader, and Ben Kenobi are one of the rarest vintage figures on the market due to Kenner pulling the telescoping saber early in production.

For more information on this rare saber and why it's double-telescoping, visit theSWCA.com. If you happen to have one, contact us immediately.
Do you buy any toylines not listed?
Yes, we are actively expanding on the brands and lines we purchase. For example, we are seeking several toylines such as Angry Birds, Pokémon, Jurassic Park, Toy Store but currently do not provide a checklist form.



Brand/toyline not listed? Send us a list of UPCs & names of any collection and we will send you a quote!

  • We Buy More Brands!

Brian's Toys Inc
W730 State Road 35
Fountain City, WI 54629
Tel: 608.687.7572 ext. 3
Fax: 608.687.7573
Email: buying@brianstoys.com